The latest performance numbers for Ivy League endowments have been nicely displayed in the chart below along with the 60/40 stock/bond portfolio. Since the development of the “endowment” model associated with Yale and the attention on Harvard, the largest endowment, there has been an unusual focus on these funds. There is a fair amount of dispersion between the best and worst managers in the group.
Dan Fuss, the Loomis Sayles bond guru, has been working in fixed income for decades. He has developed a set of four “P’s” with central bank behavior for looking at the macro fixed income environment and his read is suggesting that caution should be applied to any forecast that believes bonds are safe.
The spider chart is an alternative way of displaying data that may be useful at showing the strong diversification benefits versus different asset classes and alternatives. Correlations are looked at through a matrix form but the spider or radar graph may better display the most relevant information. Each node on the web may represent a different asset class and show the correlation of each to a single strategy.
Unlike earlier financial disasters, this one will emerge not because of too much speculation, but because of the inverse – too much hedging.
-William Silber on stock market in August 1987
Could this be the problem we are facing with the next financial crisis? There has a significant amount of talk about over-valuation in equities and the reach for yield in fixed income, but there has been less focus on how a financial crisis will evolve. It may not be from speculators changing their views on the market although this could be a catalyst. Selling could be driven by investors who are trying to hedge or mitigate their risk exposures.
From the Minneapolis Fed we have market-based probabilities of a large up or down market move embedded in 12-month options. This is a good market-based view of a large up or down stock market move.
The behavioral finance revolution has been well noted by both academics and practitioners. Multiple Nobel Prizes have gone to economists who have studied in this area, yet investment decision-makers still make the same behavioral mistakes. We have noted our biases but often we have not changed our behavior. Perhaps it is too ingrained, but good has to be reinforced.
You could call it the second reflation trade. Based on economic data trends which suggest stronger global growth coupled with tax reform/cut talk, we are seeing major sectors show increasing trends and opportunities. The good October trends seem to be carrying over to November. The reflation trades has driven stock indices, energy, and base metals prices higher. The differential between monetary policy in the US and the rest of the world also suggests dollar strengthening. The rate differential is in favor of the dollar. This dollar strength places downward pressure on precious metals. Bond price behavior has been a little surprising with some recent gains in spite of the strong growth story.
CTAs showed their strongest performance of the year in October. Only the fundamental growth strategy came close to generating the returns seen in managed futures for the month. Some strategies actually posted losses for October even with the continued increase in equity returns.
Talk of tax cuts floating through the halls of Congress coupled with stronger consumer confidence allowed risky assets to continue marching higher. Warnings of overvalued equities, concerns over leverage, and higher geopolitical risks, have not stopped stocks from stronger gains around the globe. For US companies in the third quarter, 76% have shown positive earnings surprises and 67% have had positive sales surprises. The earnings growth rate is 4.7% for the third quarter according to Factset. Positive economics, good company performance, and low volatility all contributed to this continued rally.
A simple explanation for looking at a portfolio as a bundle of diversifiable risks is presented nicely in the new book, Rational Investing; The subtleties of asset management by Hugues Langlois and Jacques Lussier, two excellent researchers and money managers.
The Bank of England research piece, Eight centuries of the risk-free rate: bond market reversals from the Venetians to the ‘VaR shock’ by Paul Schmelzing, is important reading for any investor. It places the current bond rally which has been going on for over three decades in the long term context of the last 700 years. This bond bull movement is exceptional but not yet extraordinary when look at through history. Unfortunately, all bond rallies will end, but the reasons for ending may vary.
The positive performance of risk parity products has been sneaking up on clients after poor returns in 2015. This long-only product have done much better than many other multi-asset hedge fund strategies in the last year with the HFR 12% vol institutional index being up 9.46% through September; however, it has been riding the wave of asset price mispricing or overvaluation.
What makes a good investment manager? One trait not often talked about is curiosity. You cannot find new or unique opportunities if you are not curious; however, the concept or meaning of curiosity for investment management may be hard to define.